Choosing between a pedal e-bike and a throttle e-bike is like deciding between a classic bicycle experience and a modern twist of instant power. Both offer unique ways to amplify your ride, but which one aligns with your cycling style? Let’s break down the excitement and find out which e-bike truly matches your journey.
What Is a Pedal E-Bike?
A pedal e-bike, also known as a pedal-assist e-bike or pedelec, is a bicycle with a motor. The motor only engages when you pedal, making it easier to tackle hills, headwinds, and long distances. The amount of assistance you have is based on which level you choose. Most pedal e-bikes have three of four assistance levels to suit how energetic you're feeling. For example, the lowest mode, often called "eco mode," gives you a little bit of assistance, usually around 50%. However, higher assistance modes can boost your pedaling by up to 250%, depending on the manufacturer.
Pedal e-bikes have a limited top-assisted speed. Once you reach this speed, the motor cuts out. You can still ride faster than this speed with hard pedaling; it's just that the motor no longer helps you.
Pedal E-Bike: Pros and Cons
Pros
Good for exercise: You have to pedal to make the bike move. This encourages physical activity and is excellent for getting fit.
- More natural: If you're used to riding a regular bike, you'll feel at home on a pedal e-bike. It's incredibly intuitive, and the motor just amplifies your efforts.
- You can ride further: By contributing to the bike's movement, you can ride it long distances.
- Less battery drain: The motor only engages when needed, conserving battery power and adding to your e-bike's range.
- More accepted legally: Pedal e-bikes, especially Class 1 models, are allowed on more bike paths, trails, and lanes than throttle e-bikes.
Cons
Physical effort required: You need to pedal before the motor kicks in, which may be tiring for some.
Slower starts: Starting from a standstill or riding uphill requires more effort before the motor engages.
What Is a Throttle E-Bike?
A throttle e-bike is an electric bike you can ride without pedaling. You control the motor by twisting a grip, pressing a thumb lever, or using a button to propel yourself forward. You can pedal some throttle e-bikes, but there are ones without pedals at all, making the experience similar to riding a scooter or moped.
The throttle gives you a quick boost to start from a standstill or climb a steep hill. You can use it to rest your legs or commute without getting sweaty.
Throttle E-Bike: Pros and Cons
Pros
Effortless riding: You don't have to pedal at all, making it ideal for anyone who wants to get around effortlessly.
- Easy starts: No effort is required to get going; the motor does it all for you.
- Versatility: Ebikes with both throttle and pedal assist give you the best of both worlds.
- Accessibility: Throttle e-bikes are perfect for people with mobility issues and those recovering from injuries.
Cons
- Battery drain: Constantly using the throttle depletes the battery quickly.
- Less range: You can't ride as far as you completely rely on the battery.
- Less exercise: There's less opportunity for physical exercise, negatively affecting your fitness.
- Legal restrictions: Throttle e-bikes are subject to stricter regulations in some areas and may be banned from specific bike paths and trails.
Comparing The Ownership Experience: Pedal vs. Throttle
Let's go into the different aspects of owning each of these types of e-bikes:
Riding
When it comes to pedal e-bikes, the pedal-assist mode gives you a smooth, natural ride. The motor seamlessly kicks in as you pedal, propelling you forward with less effort. This type of e-bike is perfect for riders who enjoy cycling but want a little help, especially when tackling hills or long distances.
Throttle e-bikes offer a slightly different experience. When you twist a throttle or push a button, the motor accelerates you forward immediately, even from a complete stop. This is particularly handy in urban settings where you need to start and stop frequently. The throttle allows you to ride without pedaling, providing a more relaxed and effortless experience. However, the sudden bursts of speed can feel less controlled compared to the gradual assistance of pedal e-bikes.
Costs
Pedal e-bikes and throttle e-bikes can vary dramatically in price, depending on the brand, battery size, motor power, and features. You'll notice that throttle e-bikes are often more expensive due to the engineering required to add the throttle mechanism. However, the price difference between the two types isn't significant, and you can find both budget-friendly and high-end versions.
Maintenance
When it comes to maintenance, you have to look after both types of bikes to keep them running smoothly and reliably. For example, you must check the tires, battery, gears, and brakes with both. However, throttle e-bikes may need additional attention on the throttle mechanism and related electronics. But, whichever one you choose, they are relatively low-maintenance compared to traditional motorized vehicles, and most issues can be addressed with basic tools and knowledge.
Pedal E-Bike And Throttle E-Bikes From Fiido
Here are some excellent examples of Fiido e-bikes that come under each category:
Pedal Assist - Fiido C21
The Fiido C21 is a fantastic pedal-assist e-bike that looks much like a stylish regular bike. Inside its sleek frame lies a mid-mounted 250W motor powered by a 208.8Wh battery. This, along with its 9-speed drivetrain, gives you up to 100km (62 miles) between charges. The motor is one of the unique features of this bike, as it is virtually silent, creating a more relaxed riding experience. It is also incredibly lightweight, so maneuvering and handling it is super easy. On top of all this, the Fiido C21 has hydraulic disc brakes for the ultimate control and stopping power.
- Motor - Mivice M070 250W
- Battery - DMEGC 208.8Wh
- Range - About 100 km (62 miles)
- Max Speed - 24 kph (15 mph)
Fiido E-Gravel C21 Electric Bike
Urban communter electric bike with torque sensor, only 38.58 lbs.
Pure Throttle - Fiido Q2
The Fiido Q2 is a cross between an e-scooter and an e-bike. You sit on it like a regular bike, but instead of pedals connected to a drivetrain, it is propelled solely by its motor via a throttle; just put your feet on the footpegs and go! Q2 is equipped with a thumb throttle, which can be operated with the thumb and is easy to use.Thanks to its nimbleness and high top speed of 45kph (28mph), it is one of the most fun ways to get around. The Fiido Q2 is a two-wheel drive with a 400W motor in the front wheel hub and an 800W motor in the rear. This means you have lots of power at your disposal for fast commuting and entertaining rides. To keep all this power in check, the Q2 has powerful hydraulic disc brakes that work fantastically well in all weather conditions.
- Motor - 400W in the front wheel and 800W in the rear
- Battery - 1,253Wh
- Range - Around 100km (62 miles)
- Max Speed - 45kph (28mph)
Fiido Q2 Dual Drive Foldable Electric Scooter
1200W Powerful motors and long-range all in a mini body.
Pedal Assist And Throttle - Fiido T1 Pro
The Fiido T1 Pro gives you the best of both worlds. You can use the pedal assist mode to get some exercise and extend range or the throttle mode to rest your legs or arrive without looking hot and sweaty. Its massive 960Wh battery gives you up to 150 km (93 miles) of range while pedaling. When just using the throttle, you can get around 96km (60 miles) from a single charge, so you should have enough battery power for a great day out. The 750W motor makes riding uphill and carrying heavy loads a piece of cake. The Fiido T1 Pro is an excellent choice for people carrying lots of cargo and those who like to spend lots of time in the great outdoors.
- Motor - 750W
- Battery - 960Wh
- Range - Around 96km (60 miles) with the throttle and 150 km (93 miles) using pedal assist.
- Max Speed - 45kph (28mph)
Fiido T1 Pro Utility Electric Bike
Powerful utility electric bike with 93 miles range.
Legal Considerations: Where Can You Ride?
Before buying an e-bike, you need to be aware of the local e-bike laws in your area. Regulations may dictate which type of e-bike you can ride. Pedal e-bikes are generally allowed on bike paths, trails, and lanes where traditional bicycles are permitted, especially Class 1 e-bikes. Throttle e-bikes, particularly Class 2 e-bikes, are often not allowed on specific paths and trails.
E-bike laws vary throughout the US, so it's essential for you to check what you're permitted to ride to stay safe and out of trouble.
Conclusion
Choosing between a pedal e-bike and a throttle e-bike largely depends on what you want to use it for. If you want a more traditional cycling experience, with a little help, buy a pedal e-bike. On the other hand, if you want flexibility and the option to rest while still moving, get a throttle e-bike. However, examples like the Fiido T1 Pro allow you to choose between the pedal assist and the throttle whenever you feel like it.
Think about your daily routine, fitness goals, and where you'll ride most often. Both types of e-bikes are excellent ways of commuting, exploring new places, or just having fun. But when you get the perfect e-bike for your needs, you'll enjoy owning it much more.
