If you are looking for an electric bicycle for yourself or dear ones and are unable to choose between the two most-selling brands Fiido and RIDE1UP, this article is only for you. Here we are going to compare top electric bicycle models from off-road, lightweight, and carbon fiber electric bicycles. So, let's dive deep into the deal of each category of e-bike to reach the final purchasing decision.
Off-Road Electric Bicycle Comparison: Fiido Titan vs. RIDE1UP Prodigy XC
If you are looking to buy an off-road electric bicycle and are stuck between Fiido Titan Cargo Electric Bike and RIDE1UP Prodigy XC. Both e-bikes look similar in specifications and price range. This expert review will go through deep analysis by examining all the key factors and points of difference. Each bike has distinct strengths and weak points. However, their suitability will depend on the specific rider's needs, from raw power to comfort and range.
Endurance
a. Battery Capacity and Range
- Fiido Titan Battery: 696Wh 48V 14Ah with up to 84 miles.
- RIDE1UP Prodigy XC Battery: 36V 14Ah Phylion 30-50 miles range.
Being an electric bicycle battery is the deciding factor for the estimated range. Fiido Titan e-bike has a 696Wh Samsung battery with 48V 14Ah parameters that can easily give 84 miles range. Moreover, Fiido provides 2 additional 48V 14Ah batteries extending the range to 248 miles with fitted covers and a rack to carry the batteries. Whereas RIDE1UP Prodigy XC operates a 36V 14Ah battery generating enough power to give 30 to 50 miles range in a single charge. For riders prioritizing long-distance rides or adventures in remote areas, the Fiido Titan’s superior range is a significant advantage.
Power Performance
a. Motor Power
- Fiido Titan Motor: 750W rear hub motor.
- RIDE1UP Prodigy XC Motor: Brose TF Sprinter mid-drive motor.
A powerful motor is an essential element that works as the heart of an ebike when climbing steep or off-road riding. Keeping in view, Fiido Titan is equipped with a 750W,If you prioritize speed, the higher power of the 750W motor allows for more stable performance during high-speed cruising, offering a faster top speed. It is also better suited for long-distance riding with smoother output.
b. Top speed
- Fiido Titan Top Speed: 15 mph locked, 28mph unlocked
- RIDE1UP Prodigy XC Top Speed: 28mph
In top speed terms, Fiido Titan and RIDE1UP Prodigy XC stand on the same page at 28 mph with pedal assist. However, Fiido Titan is locked at 15.5mph but can be unlocked to achieve 28mph. It has more escalation and can achieve top speed easily due to 70Nm torque.
Suspension System
a. Suspension Technology and Effectiveness
- Fiido Titan Suspension: Aluminum alloy hydraulic front suspension fork with 60mm travel.
- RIDE1UP Prodigy XC Suspension: air suspension with 120mm travel.
Those riders who prioritize comfort even in off-road riding must know how these two electric bicycles will perform. Fiido Titan has an aluminum alloy hydraulic front suspension fork with 60mm travel. However, the 135mm opening width allows the fork to be compatible with wider wheels and tires. A front fork with a wider opening width can generally improve riding stability, especially at high speeds and on rough roads. A wider front fork can enhance the rigidity of the front wheel, reduce the left and right shaking of the front wheel during intense movement or bumpy sections, and keep the wheel running straight and stable.
Durability and Load Capacity
- Fiido Titan Load Capacity: 200kg (440 lbs total, with rear rack support for cargo).
- RIDE1UP Prodigy XC Load Capacity: 300 lbs.
The Fiido Titan shines in this category, offering an impressive total load capacity of 440 lbs, including rear rack support. It is an ideal choice for those riders who carry heavy cargo while traveling. The rear rack can carry 80 kg weight with 120 kg of rider weight. In contrast, the RIDE1UP Prodigy XC is limited to a 300 lbs (136 kg) load and can be restrictive for heavier riders or those who carry more luggage.
User Experience
a. Handling & Control
- Fiido Titan: Pedal assist, throttle mode, and five levels of power assist versatile control.
- RIDE1UP Prodigy XC: Pedal assist up to Class 3.
The Fiido Titan offers more riding modes (throttle, pedal-assist, and pure electric), providing greater flexibility in control. Riders can easily switch between modes depending on terrain and battery conservation needs.
b. Safety
- Fiido Titan: Hydraulic disc brakes with power cutoff.
- RIDE1UP Prodigy XC: Tektro four-piston hydraulic brakes
Fiido Titan's hydraulic disc brake with power-off function can immediately cut off the motor, which is particularly suitable for the safe riding needs of electric bicycles.
Although the Tektro four-piston brake does not have a power-off function, its braking performance can provide the same safety at high speeds or in complex road conditions. However, Fiido Titan's hydraulic disc brake system with power-off function has lower maintenance costs and is easier to install and use.
Price and Value for Money
- Fiido Titan: $1,499
- RIDE1UP Prodigy XC: $1,495
Both bikes are similarly priced, but they cater to different rider preferences. The Fiido Titan Cargo Electric Bike, with its more powerful motor, greater load capacity, and extended range, offers exceptional value for riders seeking performance and versatility.
Reasons to Choose Fiido Titan
Fiido Titan Cargo Electric Bike has the upper hand in many ways. It provides a powerful motor with extended battery packs. Stable realistic hydraulic suspension, lightweight frame, and high payload capacity. Fiido stands to shine with an extended feature in a compatible price range. Here are some of the key aspects that make Fiido Titan a prior choice over RIDE1UP Prodigy XC.
- Greater load capacity, making it ideal for long journeys or heavy riders.
- Better range for extended rides.
- More versatile riding modes for different terrains.
Fiido Titan Robust Cargo Electric Bike
A powerhouse with a 248-mile range and 4-piston brakes, ideal for hunting and fishing trips.
Lightweight Electric Bicycle Comparison: Fiido C21 vs. RIDE1UP Roadster V3
Weight and Portability
- Fiido C21 weight and frame type: 38.6 lbs step over frame
- RIDE1UP Roadster V3 weight and frame type: 39 lbs step over frame
Both electric bicycles have almost the same weight. However, Fiido C21 is 1.4 in lightweight weight with 38.6 overall body weight making the e-bike easy to handle. In terms of frame, both electric bicycles come with a step-over frame alloy frame. Fiido C21 has a 700C aluminum alloy integrated battery urban gravel frame. On the other hand, the RIDE1UP Roadster V3 frame is an internally protected and locked electric alloy frame.
Power and Efficiency
a. Motor Power
- Fiido C21 Motor: 250W (Mivice M080)
- RIDE1UP Roadster V3 Motor: 500W Mivice hub motor.
Fiido C21 has a 250W Movie M080 electric motor in the rare wheel with a Mivice torque sensor for smooth acceleration. It can provide 15.5mph top speed which can be unlocked to 28mph. Although the Fiido C21 is more conservative, it prioritizes efficiency and range over raw speed. However, to ensure that customers have more options, the Fiido C21 speed can reach 28mph by unlocking it.
b. Range
- Fiido C21 Range: 62 miles
- RIDE1UP Roadster V3 Range: 20 - 40 miles
If you are concerned about getting more range in a single charge Fiido C21 can be the ideal choice with its 60 miles per charge range. However, RIDE1UP Roadster V3 is a good choice for short trips and good acceleration due to its 20 - 40 mile range. Overall, for urban commuters who need to balance speed with battery conservation, the C21 may offer more sustainable power output.
Riding Comfort
a. Seat and Handlebar Design
The Fiido C21 offers superior riding comfort compared to the RIDE1UP Roadster V3. It has a well-designed 640mm aluminum alloy handlebar wide enough for full control with TPR non-slip grips and a VELO vacuum full-fit saddle suitable for long rides. Moreover, the Mivice torque sensor makes each ride smooth and responsive. However, the RIDE1UP Roadster V3’s ergonomic handlebars and Selle Royale Vivo saddle are more aggressive .
Control and Safety
a. Sensor Sensitivity
- Fiido C21 Sensor: Mivice torque sensor S200
- RIDE1UP Roadster V3 Sensor: Intui-Drive
Fiido is equipped with a more efficient and intelligent torque sensor. The Mivice S200 in Fiido C21 is responsive and adjusts the power with the paddling of the rider making a natural and intuitive riding experience.
Reasons to choose Fiido C21
Fiido C21 is the ultimate choice for the rider looking for comfort, long-range, and adaptability. Fiido C21 e-bike has a 250W low-power motor ideal for achieving a long range of 62 miles. Whereas, the mivice torque sensor adjusts the power and adapts to the rider's needs. Moreover, the price difference and control and safety of Fiido C21 are also catching elements of choosing this electric bicycle.
Fiido E-Gravel C21 Electric Bike
Urban communter electric bike with torque sensor, only 38.58 lbs.
Carbon Fiber Electric Bicycle Comparison: Fiido Air vs. RIDE1UP CF RACER1
Material and Craftsmanship
Both Fiido Air and RIDE1UP CF Racer1 are carbon fiber electric bicycles. Fiido Air has 29.8 lbs weight including the battery while RIDE1UP CF Racer1 has 28.6 lbs weight, only 1.2 lbs difference. Otherwise, both have concealed wiring and electronics inside the frame with ISO 4210 and TUV strength tested. Being a lightweight design enables easy handling and movability through all terrains.
Performance Enhancements
a. Top speed
Being a carbon fiber electric bicycle you can expect many performance enhancements in both models. First of all, in terms of average speed RIDE1UP CF Racer1 has 28 mph high speed, whereas Fiido Air is locked at 15.4mph but can be unlocked to achieve 28mph.
b. Acceleration and torque
Due to its lightweight, Fiido Air e-bike can effortlessly achieve top speed and boost its climbing capabilities with the 35nm torque enhanced with the Mivice S200 intelligent torque sensor. However, the CF Racer1 comes with 42 nm torque which is higher than Fiido Air. However, Fiido Air’s Mivice S200 torque sensor equalizes the performance as CF Racer1 has the traditional cadence system.
c. Durability and Maintenance
Both eclectic bicycles are built with durable carbon-based materials with high-quality standards. However, Fiido Air has the upper hand with a 36-month frame warranty providing metal peace. On the opposite RIDE1UP CF Racer1 backs a 12-month warranty which is 3 times lower.
Advance configurations
From an advanced features perspective, Fiido Air has a 2.4-inch color LCD for a clear view even in broad daylight. Moreover, it can be connected with a smartphone or watch for easy access. But the RIDE1UP CF RACER1 has a 1.5-inch velofox center mount color display for real-time stats. Similarly, Fiido Air has an S200 Mivice torque sensor much more intelligent in operation and adjusts to riders' paddling habits. On the other hand, the RIDE1UP CF RACER1 current-based cadence sensor is less precise than a torque sensor. Overall, Fiido Air has more compelling advanced features compared to RIDE1UP CF RACER1.
Reasons to Choose Fiido Air
Fiido Air is the best carbon electric bicycle choice for several reasons. It is a cheaper, advanced torque sensor, with high payload capacity, and is more durable due to a high battery warranty. The better utilization of advanced technology, increased comfort, lightweight efficiency, and affordability are the reasons to choose Fiido Air.
Fiido Air Carbon Fiber E-bike
A revolutionary lightweight bike, winner of the Red Dot Award.
Final Purchase Guide
If you go with a Fiido e-bike, you'll get more powerful motor options and longer range, especially in off-road models like the Titan. The Fiido C21 also offers excellent riding comfort and handling, with a torque sensor and hydraulic brakes. The Fiido Air, on the other hand, offers better durability and lightweight performance in a carbon fiber design. However, the best way to make a final decision is to test ride one in person. Personal experience is crucial in terms of comfort, handling, and making sure the e-bike fits your needs. If you want to test the off-road performance of the Fiido Titan or the portability of the Fiido C21, test ride each e-bike to discover which best suits your riding style and preferences.You can find a dealer near you for a test ride on the Fiido official website https://fiido.com/pages/test-rides ，Keep in mind that Fiido's frame warranty is three years, not just the Fiido Air.
Data source: Fiido.com
ride1up.com
Date: September 2024
